Velvet Ropes logo
Shop
Where Did Rex Heuermann Live? | More on Gilgo Beach Murders

Google Maps

Inside the Gilgo Beach Murders

Sarah Paschall
Sarah Paschall
  • In 2023, a man named Rex Heuermann was arrested for the murders of 3 women found on Gilgo Beach in Long Island, NY.
  • Heuermann is also believed to be responsible for a 4th victim’s murder and possibly more.
  • The remains of at least 10 people have been discovered on or near Gilgo Beach.
  • Most of the unidentified victims located on or around Gilgo Beach have been identified.
  • Authorities believe Heuermann may have carried out the murders at his home.
  • Heuermann’s residence is only 30 minutes from where the Gilgo Four were located.
Where Did Rex Heuermann Live? | More on Gilgo Beach Murders
Getty Images

The Gilgo Beach murders, a notorious unsolved case, unfolded in Babylon, New York, and involved a series of gruesome murders and disappearances, primarily targeting women, many of whom were sex workers. These chilling crimes were discovered in 2010, prompting extensive investigations and media attention. In 2023, a significant break in the case occurred after law enforcement arrested a local man, Rex Heuermann, for the slayings – reigniting interest in this long-standing mystery. But how did detectives track down the Gilgo Beach serial killer? Where was this monster hiding for over a decade? VR is giving you an up-to-date breakdown of the case below.

Where Did Rex Heuermann Live?

Rex Heuermann’s residence in Massapequa Park, NY, has emerged as a grim focal point of recent notoriety after he was charged with the murders of 3 women found dead on Gilgo Beach.

Surprisingly, his home presents a stark contrast to the suburban surroundings. The small, red, and seemingly dilapidated house is a genuine eyesore for the locals. It stands as a relic of a bygone era, constructed in 1956. With just 1,323 square feet of interior space, it’s a stark reminder of past architectural styles.

Where Did Rex Heuermann Live? | More on Gilgo Beach Murders
Google Maps

Heuermann acquired the property in 1998 for $195,000, but today, its worth has appreciated considerably, estimated at $561,612.

Following the arrest of Heuermann, police scoured the home for evidence, tearing apart every inch of the home during their search. Here, we see what looks to be the aftermath of their search in an office space or den.

Where Did Rex Heuermann Live? | More on Gilgo Beach Murders
Robert Macedonio

Investigators left no stone unturned during their search – even cutting open the tub in the bathroom.

Where Did Rex Heuermann Live? | More on Gilgo Beach Murders
Robert Macedonio

According to authorities, the evidence they found within the home indicates that Heuermann may have actually murdered his victims at his family’s residence while his wife and children were out of town.

Authorities confiscated over 200 firearms on Heuermann’s property – only 92 of which had permits. The firearms were located in a strange walk-in vault inside the concrete basement, protected by a large iron door.

Where Did Rex Heuermann Live? | More on Gilgo Beach Murders
Jeenah Moom | AP

Other items allegedly taken from the property included a large portrait of a woman with bruises on her face, a doll inside a glass case, and a filing cabinet.

Where Did Rex Heuermann Live? | More on Gilgo Beach Murders
Kevin C. Downs | NY Post

Police also dug a large hole in the backyard looking for further victims, finding mysterious fragments that some speculate could be pieces of bones, though more analysis is needed to determine their origin.

Below, we see investigators photographing various fragments discovered in the soil.

Where Did Rex Heuermann Live? | More on Gilgo Beach Murders
DailyMail

Upon checking his personal computer and burner phones, authorities also found an alarming amount of searches on not only the victims of the Gilgo Beach slayings, but also their families.

Now, the property has become a macabre attraction for those looking to catch a glimpse of the possible scene of multiple murders. It’s important to remember, however, that this is still a private residence where Heuermann’s (now ex) wife and 2 young children live and their privacy should be respected in this difficult time.

Who Is Rex Heuermann?

Rex Heuermann, a 59-year-old resident of Massapequa Park, a quiet village in Nassau County, was recently identified as a suspect in a series of perplexing killings that have baffled investigators and garnered national attention.

Heuermann had been leading a seemingly inconspicuous life, working as an architect in Manhattan and commuting from his peaceful suburban home. He was well-regarded by neighbors, who described him as a well-dressed, reserved individual.

Who Is Rex Heuermann? | More on Gilgo Beach Murders Investigation
James Carbone-Pool | Getty Images

Some had only brief interactions with him and his family over the years, as the Heuermann’s tended to keep to themselves.

Heuermann, who operated RH Consultants & Associates, obtained his architecture license in 1996 and maintained a clean professional record.

His diverse clientele included organizations such as Catholic Charities, New York City’s Department of Environmental Protection, and American Airlines, where he served as an architectural consultant and troubleshooter, emphasizing his expertise in city architectural codes.

Gilgo Beach Victims

When it comes to cases like this, it’s important not to forget that those who were murdered were more than just discarded remains. Here are the names of those located at or around Gilgo Beach:

Melissa Barthelemy (24), Maureen Brainard-Barnes (25), Amber Costello (27), Megan Waterman (22). These are the women known as the “Gilgo Four” that authorities believe were murdered by Rex Heuermann.

Gilgo Beach Victims | More on the Gilgo Beach Murders Investigation.
Suffolk County Police Department

Jessica Taylor (Age 20)

Gilgo Beach Victims | More on Gilgo Beach Murders
Gilgonews.com

Karen Vergata (Age 34)

Gilgo Beach Victims | More on Gilgo Beach Murders
DNASolves.com

Valerie Mack (Age 24)

Gilgo Beach Victims | More on Gilgo Beach Murders
Gilgonews.com

Unidentified Asian Male (Age 17-23)

Gilgo Beach Victims | More on Gilgo Beach Murders
Gilgonews.com

Unidentified Toddler (Approximately Age 2)

Unidentified Female – known as “Peaches” (Approximately Age 16-30)

The photos show Peaches’ tattoo, the inspiration for her name, and the jewelry she was wearing.

Gilgo Beach Victims | More on Gilgo Beach Murders
Long Island Press

Anyone with new information on the case can submit a tip to the Suffolk County Police Department.

The Gilgo Beach Murders

The case of the Gilgo Beach murders has baffled investigators for over a decade, with multiple victims being found over the years with no answer as to who was responsible for their murders. While investigating, authorities have located around 10 different sets of remains in the area. Some details on the victims are lacking, but this is what we have currently:

The first discovery of remains came in April 1996, when a pair of severed legs wrapped in plastic were discovered on Blue Point Beach in Suffolk County – the remains came to be known as “Fire Island Jane Doe.” Her skull was later located in 2011 near Ocean Parkway. A DNA test carried out in 2022 revealed that Jane Doe was a woman by the name of Karen Vergata of Manhattan, NY.

On December 11, 2010, as police searched for another missing woman, they located the skeletonized remains of Melissa Barthelemy wrapped in burlap and left in a patch of thick brush on Gilgo Beach.

On December 13, 2010, the remains of Amber Costello, Maureen Brainard-Barnes, and Megan Waterman were located less than 500 feet apart from each other.

On March 29, 2011, the remains of Jessica Taylor were located along Ocean Parkway during a search for missing Shannan Gilbert. Part of Jessica’s remains had been found previously in a wooded area of Manorville in July 2003.

On April 4th, 2011, the remains of three additional victims were located: An Asian male (age 17-23), a female toddler (approx. age 2), and Valerie Mack (also known as Jane Doe #6). Valerie’s remains were also found in two separate locations – in Manorville in 2000 and Oak Beach in 2011.

On April 11, 2011, the partial remains of a Jane Doe, referred to as “Peaches” due to the peach tattoo on her chest, were located near Jones Beach. Some of her remains had been located initially back in June 1997 in a bin at Hempstead Lake State Park. DNA carried out in 2022 revealed Peaches to be the mother of the toddler found further down the parkway.

Detectives on the case have yet to rule out the possibility that some of the other victims outside of the Gilgo Four were carried out by Heuermann. However, they do believe some of the killings were done by other perpetrators.

Gilgo Beach Murder Map

The four women that Rex Heuermann is accused of murdering were found a mere 30 minutes from the Heuermann family home and roughly 500 feet from each other. Unfortunately, they are far from the first or last remains to be located in the area.

Gilgo Beach Murder Map | More on Gilgo Beach Murders
Google Maps

Several other bodies were located along the same stretch of shoreline (pictured below), but Heuermann is currently only charged with 3 of the murders at this time.

Gilgo Beach Murder Map | More on Gilgo Beach Murders
Atiru | Wikipedia

Gilgo Beach Murders Investigation

In the chilling case of Megan Costello’s disappearance in 2010, her roommate, Dave Schaller, played a crucial role in providing detectives with a distinctive description of a man he encountered during that fateful period.

How Did They Find The Gilgo Beach Killer? | More on the Gilgo Beach Murder Investigation
A&E

Schaller portrayed the man as a towering figure with a haunting “empty gaze” who drove a first-generation Chevy Avalanche. His encounter with the stranger turned violent when Schaller returned home to discover Costello locked in the bathroom, with the menacing man threatening her from outside.

A physical altercation ensued between Schaller and the man, who hastily fled the scene in his truck. Tragically, on September 2, 2010, Schaller witnessed Costello leaving their residence to meet the same client, never to return again. Another witness spotted the ominous truck passing by Costello’s home shortly after her departure.

Despite Schaller’s early and vital tip to the police, it languished for years with little investigation. It wasn’t until 2022 when Suffolk County District Attorney, Ray Tierney, took over the case, that a renewed effort to uncover the Gilgo Beach killer was initiated.

Schaller’s information was revisited, and vehicle records revealed that Rex Heuermann not only owned a Chevy Avalanche but had also resided within a neighborhood pinpointed by a search grid based on cellphone location data from the time of Costello’s disappearance.

The failure to pursue Schaller’s lead earlier could be attributed to the chaotic backdrop of that time, characterized by divisions among law enforcement agencies and a series of scandals. This included the imprisonment of Suffolk County District Attorney, Thomas Spota, and the controversial tenure of James Burke as head of the Suffolk County police department.

Burke’s tenure saw the cessation of FBI cooperation on the case due to federal scrutiny of his own misconduct, leading to a subsequent prison sentence for attempting to conceal the assault of a man who discovered adult toys and pornography in his car.

How Did They Find the Gilgo Beach Killer?

The new task force assigned to catching the Gilgo Beach killer first utilized Schaller’s earlier tips about his encounter with the violent stranger as a starting point. Tracking down Heuermann, they arrested him outside his Midtown office.

Police took a pizza crust Heuermann had discarded in a Manhattan garbage can and cross-referenced it to hair found on a burlap sack Waterman’s body was wrapped in. The DNA was a match.

As he was being booked following his arrest, Heuermann simply asked “Is it in the news?”

How Did They Find The Gilgo Beach Killer? | More on the Gilgo Beach Murders Investigation.
John Roca | Newsday

Gilgo Beach Murders Update 2023

As of October 2023, Heuermann is in prison – charged with 3 counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman, and Amber Costello.

Heuermann is also the primary suspect in the disappearance of Maureen Brainard-Barnes, though he hasn’t been charged in that homicide as of yet.

In addition to helping the family’s of the Gilgo Four finally find closure, there has also been an effort to ensure others found at Gilgo Beach are given their identity back. Two weeks after Heuermann’s arrest, it was announced that the remains of an unknown woman, called “Fire Island Jane Doe”, had been identified as belonging to Karen Vergata.

Vergata was a 34-year-old escort that worked out of Manhattan and went missing on Valentine’s Day back in 1996.

Police in both Las Vegas and South Carolina are also reviewing cold cases to see if any bare a resemblance to the Gilgo Beach slayings. Heuermann had spent time in South Carolina and planned on retiring there. He also owns a timeshare in Vegas’s Club De Soleil that he purchased for around $17,000 in 2005.

Sources

https://www.cnn.com/2023/08/01/us/gilgo-beach-suspect-home-photos/index.html

https://www.cnn.com/2023/07/15/us/gilgo-beach-murder-case-timeline/index.html

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12333333/What-DID-Experts-split-bone-like-fragments-dug-Gilgo-Beach-serial-killer-suspect-Rex-Heuermanns-backyard-claim-human-remains-ruled-out.html

https://nypost.com/2023/07/17/gilgo-beach-investigators-remove-portrait-of-battered-woman-from-rex-heuermanns-home/

https://abcnews.go.com/US/gilgo-beach-murders-timeline-investigation/story?id=101428812

https://www.cnn.com/2023/08/04/us/investigation-update-gilgo-beach-murders/index.html

https://nypost.com/2023/07/19/rex-heuermann-probes-now-span-several-states-after-gilgo-beach-arrest/

https://dnasolves.com/articles/fire-island-jane-doe-gilgo-murders/

https://nypost.com/2023/08/04/gilgo-beach-victim-jane-doe-no-7-identified-as-investigation-continues/

https://www.gilgonews.com/victims

Categories:
New York
True Crime Locations
TV
Sarah Paschall
Written by

Sarah Paschall

Sarah has written and edited for numerous media outlets in a variety of different niches – though entertainment is her all-time favorite topic to cover. When she is not hard at work researching and writing about Hollywood’s top talents for Velvet Ropes, Sarah enjoys working on her fiction novels, developing her blog, and gaming. You can follow Sarah on Twitter at: Twitter.com/tuspock91