Jimmy Fallon's House in Sagaponack, and the Gramercy Park Apartments He Sold

Jimmy Fallon, host of The Tonight Show since 2014, and his wife, the film producer Nancy Juvonen, bought a house in Sagaponack, a farm village on the South Fork of Long Island, in 2011. It is the one the family kept: Hello magazine still placed them there in 2023, and the Town of Southampton's record shows no sale since 2011. In Manhattan they kept a home for 20 years, five apartments in one Gramercy Park co-op, bought one at a time from 2002 on and all of it sold in the summer of 2022.

Sagaponack became a village of its own in September 2005. In 2020 it was also where the show came from for four months, while Fallon hosted it from home.

The town's sale record and the map pin are on Jimmy Fallon's house in Sagaponack.

Bought through a trust in 2011

Gawker reported in 2011 that Fallon was closing on a house in Sagaponack. He bought it through a trust.

The show from home

When New York shut down in March 2020, Fallon took The Tonight Show home, and Hello magazine places those broadcasts at the Sagaponack house. The format lasted until mid-July, when the show went back to its Manhattan studio without an audience, as the Associated Press reported.

The indoor slide viewers saw in those broadcasts was Juvonen's idea. In an April 2020 segment she told Today she had drawn it on an index card before anyone built it: "I drew that slide coming down, and then once you draw it, I think you can bring it to life." The family uses it "all the time," she said, and she rides it down with armloads of laundry.

Five apartments in one Gramercy Park co-op

The Manhattan home was built up over 12 years, and Jimmy Fallon's former Gramercy Park apartment has its own page, with the purchase record and the 2022 sale.

The five are co-op apartments (not condos, as our 2021 page said), which is why the city's record of them reads the way it does. A co-op buyer buys shares in the building, so New York City's property register, ACRIS, records each purchase as a tax filing, not a deed. Fallon's first apartment there, a small one he bought in 2002 according to Dwell, has no filing under his name, so that purchase rests on press accounts. The ones after it are on the register, four more between 2004 and 2014.

The last of the five was the smallest, and 6sqft reported in 2014 that Fallon planned to use it as an office. The other four were joined into one home. When the couple put that home up for sale in March 2021, 6sqft reported the $15M asking price, and Dwell gave Juvonen the credit for its playful look.

The sale went through in 2022 to a buyer who bought through a trust. 6sqft reported $10.8M, the price of the combined home. With the fifth, smaller apartment, which sold on a filing of its own, the city's record comes to $11.75M, a little over three quarters of the 2021 asking price.

The house they kept is on the Sagaponack page.