Judge Judy's Houses: Greenwich Now, Newport and Naples Sold
Judy Sheindlin lives in Greenwich, Connecticut. The Newport house sold in 2025, her family sold Naples that December, and a Sutton Place co-op went up for sale in 2024.
Judge Judy lives in Greenwich, Connecticut. Judy Sheindlin, the former Manhattan family court judge whose Judge Judy ran 25 seasons from 1996 to 2021, holds the house there through a company that the 2025 Connecticut property roll lists in care of Judith Sheindlin, meaning the company's mail goes to her. The house dates from 2008. It is where USA Today interviewed her in September 2026.
As of October 2026 the portfolio stands like this: she lives in Greenwich; the Newport house sold for $15.3M in September 2025; the Naples house passed to her son and his wife, who sold it for $9.5M that December; and a Sutton Place co-op in Manhattan listed in 2024 has no reported sale. The page that stood at this URL in 2018 described a portfolio of several houses, and two of them have changed hands since. It also got several facts wrong, and the sections below correct them.
We do not print the street address, and here is why. The roll's full entry and the map are on Judge Judy Sheindlin's Greenwich home profile.
The Connecticut roll's entry for the house she lives in now, and the map.
The Greenwich house, and the one before it
Connecticut's Office of Policy and Management gathers every town assessor's records into one statewide roll, and the Greenwich entry reads plainly. The owner is a company that holds the title, with a second line reading care of Judith Sheindlin. The latest recorded sale is from 2007, and the roll dates the house standing now to 2008. That fits the one thing the 2018 page had right about Greenwich: the Sheindlins bought in 2007, then tore down what was there and built again, which Hello also reported in 2022.
That is as far as this page goes on Greenwich. Sheindlin lives there now, so we print nothing about the grounds, the size of the house, or the house that stood there before it.
Newport: the Bird House, 2018 to 2025
The Newport house was new when the Sheindlins found it. Dorrance Hill Hamilton, the Campbell Soup heiress who founded the Newport Flower Show, built it in 2012 and named it the Bird House, Boston Magazine reported. WPRI places it on part of the former Arthur Curtiss James estate, the railroad magnate's Newport property. Hamilton died in 2017. In July 2018 the Sheindlins bought the house for $9M, the most expensive home sale in Rhode Island that year, according to both Boston Magazine and Providence Business News. At the closing Sheindlin said she was “looking forward to falling in love with Newport.”
They kept it seven years. In September 2025 they sold it for $15.3M to an out-of-state company, a sale reported by WPRI and NBC 10 in Providence, by the Boston Globe from city records, and by Newport Buzz from property records. We leave the buying company unnamed. The house has its own page now: Judge Judy Sheindlin's former Newport home.
Naples: one house, two prices
In late 2015 the Sheindlins traded one Naples home for another. The AP reported that they were selling the Gulf-front penthouse at the Windsor at Bay Colony, theirs since 2005, after buying a lakefront house about a kilometer away. What they paid for the house depends on whom you read: $8.9M, according to the AP, which cited Collier County property records, or $8.6M, according to the Naples Daily News and Benzinga.
The 2018 page said she bought the house after selling a penthouse in December 2015. The AP had the order the other way round. The house came first, in November by the AP's account (the Naples Daily News says December), and the penthouse then going up for sale was the one at the Windsor, in Naples, not one in Manhattan.
The 2018 page also said she sold the house in March 2022 for $8.6M. We found no report of that sale. What the record shows is a handoff. Title, meaning ownership, passed from Sheindlin to her son Adam Levy and his wife, and the Collier County roll extract we read, from January 2026, still names them as the owners, so the roll may not yet show their sale. They sold the house on December 29, 2025, for $9.5M, according to the Naples Daily News, Benzinga and Yahoo. The years she held it are on Judge Judy Sheindlin's former Naples home.
Sutton Place: on the market since 2024
The Manhattan apartment is the part of the portfolio the 2018 page got backwards: it had a Sutton Place penthouse sold in December 2015. The Sheindlins in fact bought a co-op on Sutton Place, an apartment owned through shares in the building's corporation, in 2013 for $8.5M, and in May 2024 they put it up for sale at $9.5M, a move covered by Fox Business, TMZ and StreetEasy. “We've enjoyed this jewel of an apartment,” Sheindlin said in a statement. “Time to simplify.” Finance Monthly reported a $1M cut in June 2025, to $8.5M, the price they paid. We found no report of a sale as of October 2026.
Beverly Hills: unconfirmed
The 2018 page named one more city home, in Beverly Hills. That rests on a 2013 Variety report that Sheindlin bought there, which Hello repeated in 2022. We have not matched it to a record, and we do not know whether she still owns it.
Sources
21 sources, 10 linked
- USA Today via The Spokesman-Review, Judge Judy unfiltered (September 22, 2026)
- Connecticut Office of Policy and Management, statewide property roll (2025)
- Hello, Judge Judy's property portfolio (October 19, 2022)
- Boston Magazine, Judge Judy is now the proud owner of a Newport mansion (August 1, 2018)
- Providence Business News, Judge Judy Sheindlin purchases Bird House in Newport for $9M (July 30, 2018)
- Newport Buzz, Obituary: Dorrance Hill Hamilton (2017)
- WPRI 12 via Yahoo, Judge Judy sells Newport mansion for $15.3 million (September 30, 2025)
- NBC 10 WJAR, Judge Judy sells Newport home for $15.3M (September 30, 2025)
- The Boston Globe, Judge Judy sells Newport estate (October 1, 2025)
- Newport Buzz, Judge Judy sells Newport estate for $15.3 million (September 29, 2025)
- AP via Gulf News, Judge Judy is selling beachfront penthouse
- AP via WPTV, Judge Judy selling beachfront penthouse in Florida
- Benzinga via Yahoo, Judge Judy's Florida mansion sells for $1 million below asking price (January 6, 2026)
- Yahoo Entertainment, Judge Judy's Naples mansion sells for $9.5 million (December 30, 2025)
- Naples Daily News, This no-nonsense TV star sold Florida mansion for a cool $9.5 million (January 16, 2026)
- Collier County Property Appraiser roll, via the South Florida Water Management District parcel layer (January 2026 extract)
- Fox Business, Judge Judy lists $9.5M penthouse saying it's time to simplify (May 30, 2024)
- TMZ, Judge Judy lists New York City penthouse for $9.5 million (May 24, 2024)
- StreetEasy, Verdict in: Judge Judy's Manhattan penthouse lists for $9.5M (2024)
- Finance Monthly, on the Sutton Place price cut (June 5, 2025)
- Variety, Judge Judy buys in Beverly Hills (2013)